“Lori Dew is Acquitted” or “Justice Served?” or “Parents: Will You Please Pay Attention Now?!”
July 3rd, 2009SO, I was sitting here this morning thinking to myself, “what the heck and I going to blog about today?”
Then I checked the news.
Wow. Well, apparently the Lori Drew conviction was overturned by the judge. Lori Drew, who already got away on state and criminal laws, will now not even suffer the fate of a misdemeanor. She is 100% free. She convinced a troubled young girl to kill herself – and she will lead a free life unscathed… at least until the angry mobs get to her.
There are millions of stories posted on this out there… here are a few headlines:
- New York Times: Judge Throws Out Conviction in Cyberbullying Case
- LA Times: MySpace suicide case tentatively dismissed
- Reuters: MySpace suicide conviction tentatively dismissed
- ComputerWorld (IDG News Service): Judge temporarily dismisses MySpace cyberbully case
I won’t bother to post them because they are all similar and the general idea is thus:
U.S. District Court Judge George Wu granted a defense motion for a directed acquittal of Lori Drew.
In November, a federal jury here convicted a-hole Drew of three misdemeanor charges under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, a federal law intended to combat computer crimes. Legal experts followed the case closely, saying it was the first time the statute had been used to prosecute a patron of a social networking site for abuses of the site.
But on Thursday, Judge Wu said the federal statute was too “vague” when applied in this case and that were he to allow Ms. Drew’s conviction to stand, “one could literally prosecute anyone who violates a terms of service agreement” in any way.
So we now wait for the “final” verdict next week… but we have to look at this from two sides
SIDE ONE: Legal
This overturning was legal correct. You can’t deny that. Her violation of terms shouldn’t be a federal legal matter. It should be civil. The problem with that is, these social networking websites are businesses and run by corporations. They are in the game to make money. They will not use their own money to go after their precious users in lawsuits for simply violating an agreement that not even the law cares about. As it is, notice that MySpace didn’t get rid of any of its convicted sex offender members until it was FORCED to by all (but one) state Attorneys General in the US.
The bottom line, violating the terms of service is not a federal matter.
SIDE TWO: Parenting
On the other hand… Knowing that there is no national law to prevent cyberbullying (and I don’t think there will ever be one), if you live in a state where there is no cyberbullying statue (and MOST do not have one), the overturning of this all but confirms to the public that social networking sites are the Wild West. Now, not even the Terms of Service have any meaning. People can do what they want on there, and the federal government – in a way – back up that freedom.
So, parents… what are you going to do?
Remember: the reason behind the overturning was literally because of the “well, if everyone is doing it, it must be okay” theory. Disgusting.
THE OTHER SIDE – what they should do:
Remember when they made credit card companies be more direct with their language and fine print… why not make websites that are home to literally hundreds of millions of users do the same with the ToS. Don’t we think that if we made those ToS easier to read so there were no excuses and then held people accountable to them, a huge chunk of cyberbullying and internet predators would go away??
And don’t cry me a river about freedoms. This is about acting nice and not being an a-hole online. If you can’t do it on your own, maybe someone needs to tell you how to do it… (since obviously your parents forgot how to OR you’re too lazy to teach your own kids)…
Personally, this makes me sick, but it also proves a point: parents, no one is watching online. You are the only guardians and safety net there is for your kids, especially against cyberbullies. In the eyes of the federal government, it is okay for someone to bully your child on a social networking website to the point they kill themselves.
But I guess that’s good news for the parents of bullies who are turning their already turning their heads at or oblivious to their child’s horrible behavior. No you have nothing to worry about…
Know what your kids do online!
PC Pandora computer monitoring software
Everything else is just a guess…
Happy Friday!































