Banning kids from social networks in libraries - unconstitutional or smart?
Thursday, July 31st, 2008A USA Today article – and its subject matter – is sparking a bit of heated debate. Basically, Congress is considering a bill that would bar children who use computers in public libraries from accessing Facebook and other social networking websites without parental permission.
Of course, all the nuts are coming out of the woodwork to cry about freedoms being squashed. They are somehow trying to link this to the destruction of the 1st amendment.
I am just as liberal as the next guy, and I am very modernistic and forward-thinking - I am not a conservative at all… but what the hell is wrong with you people?
The ONLY people this bill refers to is children under 18 who want to use a library computer to go on MySpace (or Facebook, etc.).
Does it interfere with privacy and free speech? Um, what type of privacy do you expect to have at a public terminal in a public place?
One genius says: “If people in a community do not feel confident that their privacy will be protected, they cannot use the library as it was intended, for intellectual pursuit, it will intimidate them.”
“Intellectual pursuit”? It’s a social networking site… there is absolutely ZERO intellectual anything happening over there.
Secondly, you are all missing the point. The bill is meant to prevent kids from disobeying their parents – or acting behind their parents back – accessing social network sites, and using the unsupervised access to potentially engage in risky behavior, i.e. meeting with strangers, waging a cyberbullying campaign, etc.
And, hey – uh… did any of you read this? It actually says “parents permission.” This law is telling kids that they have to obey their parents. Maybe that will make a few heads of this current self-absorbed young generation. And, if a parent is fine with their kid on MySpace, all they have to do is write a freaking note so that the little internet fiend can give it to the librarian and then he can plug the LAN line into his veins and glue his face to someone else’s Space.
There is nothing wrong with this bill you freaks. Pick your battles. You want to stop something? stop the federal aid going to private financial organizations that were ignorant and irresponsible and deliberately trying to screw people when it all blew up in their faces.
Geez freaking Louise.
Here’s the article… Read the comments. OH yeah, if parents used PC Pandora at home they could keep their kids and their social networking habits in check.
Bill would ban kids from Facebook, MySpace in libraries
By Ledyard King Gannett News Service
WASHINGTON — Congress is considering a bill that would bar children who use computers in public libraries from accessing Facebook and other social networking websites without parental permission.
Rep. Mark Steven Kirk, the Illinois Republican who sponsored the measure, says the proposal would keep sexual predators from contacting minors who are using a library computer.
But the American Library Association says Kirk’s bill is yet another attempt by the federal government to interfere with library users’ privacy and free speech.
“If people in a community do not feel confident that their privacy will be protected, they cannot use the library as it was intended, for intellectual pursuit,” said Emily Sheketoff, who heads the association’s Washington office. “It will intimidate them.”
It’s the latest in a series of battles the association has been fighting with Congress over the past decade. Some highlights:
-
In 2000, lawmakers required libraries receiving federally discounted Internet service to install devices to filter out obscene material. Libraries sued, but the Supreme Court upheld the law.
-
A year later, following the 2001 terrorist attacks, Congress passed the USA Patriot Act, giving federal authorities more power to track the books and videos library patrons borrow and the websites they visit.
Despite objections from the American Library Association, the act was renewed in 2006 without significant changes, other than a requirement that authorities take extra steps in justifying their need for the records.
Supporters of the law note that two of the 2001 hijackers bought their plane tickets using a public computer at a New Jersey college library and that other members of the plot surfed the Internet using a computer at a public library in Delray Beach, Fla.
Earlier this year, a federal magistrate judge in Atlanta ruled the FBI did not violate the privacy of a Pakistani national in 2006 by logging onto the same computer the Pakistani has used and looking up which websites he had visited. Agents said the man was part of a terrorism plot.
-
In 2007, the American Library Association helped persuade Congress to reopen several Environmental Protection Agency libraries the Bush administration had closed. The closures “created a serious obstacle to the public’s ability to gather information about key environmental issues,” according to the association.
-
Kirk’s bill, the Deleting Online Predators Act, died in 2006 but gained new life this year.
Kirk says that as more children flock to social networking sites like MySpace and Facebook, “we’ve seen a corresponding increase of online sexual predators” targeting those children.
But library officials say the legislation — while tackling a legitimate problem — takes the wrong approach in trying to keep kids safe from online predators.
Rather than outlawing certain sites, the American Library Association supports preparing kids and parents to deal with online threats at the library, home or anywhere else.